Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert Kos's avatar

Interesting to read your response, and yeah, Oppenheimer felt like a sterile and intellectual film to me -- felt jarring considering the subject matter + what you've written about with how the victims of the bomb weren't part of the story.

Six months since the post, I'm curious to know if your thoughts have changed.

For my own self, I found it a forgettable film save that the bomb-detonation scene had a visceral power that hit me hard -- especially because of how the suspense had ramped up towards it in the story. It was an impressive moment but, whatever I took away from it ("nuclear bombs are powerful") wasn't something I didn't already have before.

Despite not liking it, I ended up seeing it three times in the cinema. I'd promised to different friends I'd watch it with them, and they held me to it, so I went for a different formats each time to see if it changed things (standard, IMAX, 70mm).

After having seen more than 9 hours of the movie, I'm still not sure I can say what it was trying to communicate in terms of values or messaging. I noticed different things each time, but nothing had a consistent or clear feel to it. As a result, my opinion of the film changed each time I saw it. Never in such a way that I ended up liking it, but I did appreciate certain aspects.

Expand full comment

No posts